HUD Provides Significant Clarification Regarding Income in HOTMA Final Rule

person A.J. Johnson today 11/19/2023

Introduction

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) has released Notice H 2023-10, which expands upon the Final Rule for implementing the Housing Opportunity Through Modernization Act (HOTMA). This final rule provides clarification regarding how income is determined for purposes of HUD programs and other programs that must follow HUD rules relative to the determination of income.

Annual Income

Annual income includes all amounts received from all sources by each member of the family who is 18 years of age or older, the head of household, or spouse of the head of household, in addition to unearned income received by or on behalf of each dependent who is under 18 years of age. Annual income does not include amounts specifically excluded in 24 CFR §5.609.

HUD clarifies that annual income includes "all amounts received," not the amount that a family may be legally entitled to receive but which they do not receive. For example, a family’s child support or alimony income must be based on payments received, not the amounts to which a family is entitled by court or agency orders. For this reason, a copy of a court order or other written payment agreement alone may not be sufficient verification of amounts received by a family.

Annual income also includes all actual anticipated income from assets even if the asset is excluded from net family assets but the income from the asset is not otherwise excluded. Imputed returns on net family assets are included in annual income only when net family assets exceed $50,000, and actual asset income cannot be calculated for all assets.

Day Laborers

A day laborer is defined as an individual hired and paid one day at a time without an agreement that the individual will be hired or work again in the future.

Income earned as a day laborer is considered "earned" income and must be included in the determination of income unless specifically excluded by federal regulation (e.g., earnings of full-time students in excess of the dependent deduction).

Independent Contractor

An independent contractor is an individual who qualifies as an independent contractor instead of an employee in accordance with IRS regulations and whose earnings are subject to self-employment tax.

In general, an individual is an independent contractor if they have the right to control or direct only the conduct of the work. For example, while instructions and route information are generally provided, third-party delivery and transportation service providers are considered independent contractors unless state law dictates otherwise. In addition, "gig workers," such as babysitters, landscapers, rideshare drivers, and house cleaners, typically fall into the category of independent contractors.

Income earned as an independent contractor is considered "earned" income and must be included in the determination of income unless specifically excluded by federal regulation (e.g., earnings of full-time students in excess of the dependent deduction).

Seasonal Worker

A seasonal worker is defined as an individual who is: 1) hired into a short-term position (e.g., for which the customary employment period for the job is six months or less); and 2) the employment begins about the same time each year (such as summer or winter).

Examples of seasonal work include employment limited to holidays or agricultural seasons. Seasonal work may include but is not limited to employment as a lifeguard, ballpark vendor, or snowplow driver.

Income earned as a seasonal worker is considered "earned" income and must be included in the determination of income unless specifically excluded by federal regulation.

In conclusion, Notice H 2023-10 and the Final Rule for the Housing Opportunity Through Modernization Act provide essential guidelines for determining income within HUD programs. These clarifications serve to ensure a fair and accurate assessment of income, capturing the complexities of modern work arrangements from day laborers to independent contractors and seasonal workers. By including actual received income and anticipating earnings from assets, HUD aims to streamline the process, promote transparency, and provide consistency across the board. This approach not only supports the equitable distribution of housing assistance but also reflects the evolving nature of income in a gig economy. As HUD continues to refine its policies, these measures are a step toward modernizing housing opportunities and upholding the fundamental principle that everyone deserves access to affordable housing.

Latest Articles

HUD Publishes Final Rule Updating HOME Regulations

HUD's HOME Investment Partnerships Program (also known as the HOME program or HOME) provides formula grants to states and local government units to support various activities to produce and maintain affordable rental and homeownership housing. The program also offers tenant-based rental assistance for low-income and very low-income households. This final rule updates the current HOME regulations to enhance, simplify, and streamline requirements, better align the program with other federal housing programs, and implement recent amendments to the HOME statute. Additionally, this final rule includes minor revisions to the regulations for the Community Development Block Grant and Section 8 Housing Choice Voucher Programs, consistent with the changes to the HOME program. This final rule follows the publication of a proposed rule on May 29, 2024, and incorporates the feedback received regarding that proposed rule. This final rule will be effective on February 5, 2025. The rule changes for the HOME program have been made in the following general areas: Tenant Protections and Lease Requirements: Enhanced tenant protections, including requirements for lease contents, notice provisions, tenant rights, prohibitions on unreasonable interference or retaliation by owners, and ensuring tenants' rights to organize and access common areas. Property Standards and Inspections: Updated property standards for new construction, rehabilitation, and ongoing property conditions, including requirements for carbon monoxide and smoke detection, disaster mitigation, green building standards, and revised inspection procedures and frequency requirements. Affordability and Income Determinations: Adjusted periods of affordability based on the amount of HOME funds invested, updated income determination methods, streamlined income determination processes, and provisions for accepting income determinations from other Federal or State programs. Tenant-Based Rental Assistance (TBRA): Revised requirements for rental assistance contracts, including terms, amendments, renewals, and income determinations, with enhanced tenant protections and lease addendum requirements. Community Housing Development Organizations (CHDOs): Revised CHDO qualification requirements, roles in owning, developing, and sponsoring housing, and provisions for capacity building and operating expenses. Homeownership Assistance: Updated homeownership value limits, resale and recapture provisions, requirements for lease-purchase programs, and adjusted periods of affordability for homeownership assistance. Environmental, Health, and Safety Hazards: Requirements for notifying tenants and participating jurisdictions of environmental, health, or safety hazards affecting projects or units. Program Administration and Compliance: Changes to the closeout process, recordkeeping requirements, corrective and remedial actions, and adjustments to the applicability of uniform administrative requirements and provisions for reallocations by formula. Security Deposits and Fees: Prohibitions on using surety bonds or security deposit insurance in lieu of security deposits, and requirements for refundable security deposits and allowable fees. Green Building and Resiliency: Incentives for projects meeting green building standards, allowing jurisdictions to exceed maximum per-unit subsidy limits for such projects. Utility Allowances and Rent Limits: Flexibility in determining utility allowances using HUD-approved methods and aligning rent limits with other Federal and State rental assistance programs. Financial Oversight: Annual examination of the financial condition of projects with 10 or more HOME-assisted units to ensure continued economic viability. Tenant Selection and Marketing: Requirements for written tenant selection policies, affirmative marketing, and nondiscrimination compliance. Project Costs and Eligible Activities: This section clarifies eligible project costs, including pre-development costs, environmental assessments, and using HOME funds for acquisition through ground leases. Administrative and Planning Costs: Provisions reimbursing administrative and planning costs, including project inspections and monitoring costs. While the changes are essential and must be fully understood by Participating Jurisdictions, since my practice focuses on affordable rental housing, I will also focus on that in the articles I post about them. Due to the complexity of the final rule, which is more than 500 pages, I will provide articles on the changes affecting multifamily housing complexes using HOME funds. Over the next few weeks, I will post articles on the following areas of the final rule. (1) Tenant Protections & Lease Requirements, (2) Property Standards & Inspections, (3) Affordability and Income Determinations, (4) Security Deposits & Fees, (5) Utility Allowances & Rent Limits, and (6) Tenant Selection & Marketing. These articles will assist owners and managers of rental properties with HOME funds to understand the new rules that will impact projects that obtain HOME funding beginning on February 5, 2025. If you know of an industry professional who may benefit from these articles, please encourage them to log into our website and sign up to receive automatic notification of future articles. They can subscribe to our articles by visiting our website (ajjcs.net), clicking "news, and then "subscribe in the lower right corner.

USDA Updates Audit Requirements for Rural Housing and Community Facilities Programs

On December 6, 2024, the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Rural Housing Service (RHS) issued a final rule updating audit and financial statement requirements for its Multi-Family Housing and Community Facilities programs. These changes align the agency's regulations with recent revisions from the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) regarding federal financial assistance guidance. Key Changes in Audit Thresholds The final rule implements several significant modifications to audit requirements: Community Facilities: The audit threshold for Community Facilities program participants has increased from $750,000 to $1,000,000 in federal financial assistance per fiscal year. Multi-Family Housing: Non-profit borrowers receiving $1,000,000 or more in combined federal financial assistance must now adhere to OMB audit requirements, which have been raised from the previous $750,000 threshold. For-profit borrowers and smaller non-profits: Organizations receiving less than these thresholds may submit alternative financial reports, with specific requirements based on funding levels. Financial Reporting Requirements For organizations below the audit thresholds, the rule maintains flexibility in financial reporting: Non-profit borrowers receiving less than $1 million and for-profit borrowers receiving less than $500,000 in federal assistance can submit annual owner-certified prescribed forms using the accrual method of accounting. These reports must comply with the Statements on Standards for Accounting and Review Services issued by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA). Organizations may engage a CPA to prepare compilation reports of the prescribed forms. Administrative Updates The rule also includes technical modifications to align with current federal guidance: - Removes specific CFR issue dates to allow flexibility for future updates. - Updates terminology to replace "applicant" with "recipient" or "subrecipient" where applicable. - Streamlines references to OMB guidance throughout the affected regulations. Impact and Implementation These changes are expected to lessen the administrative burden for smaller organizations while ensuring appropriate oversight of federal funds. The updated thresholds account for inflation adjustments and modern federal grant management practices. The final rule impacts multiple USDA Rural Development programs, including: - Farm Labor Housing (Section 514) - Rural Rental Housing (Section 515) - Community Facilities Programs - Rural Business-Cooperative Service initiatives Organizations receiving USDA Rural Development funding should review these new requirements to ensure compliance with the appropriate audit and financial reporting standards based on their federal assistance levels. For more information, affected organizations can contact Julie Felhofer, chief of the Policy & Budget Branch, at 715-295-4069, Julie.felhofer@USDA.gov, or Nathan Chitwood, Director of Community Facilities at USDA Rural Development, at 573-876-0965, Nathan.chitwood@USDA.gov. This rule is part of the USDA's ongoing efforts to modernize its regulations, align them with government-wide standards for federal financial assistance programs, and ensure effective oversight of federal funds.

HUD Issues Final Rule Updating HOME Investment Partnerships Program

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) has announced a significant update to the HOME Investment Partnerships (HOME) program regulations. This final rule, which will be published in the Federal Register on January 6, 2025, aims to modernize and streamline program requirements and ensure better alignment with other federal housing initiatives. Here is a detailed overview of the changes and their implications for stakeholders. Key Highlights of the Final Rule Simplification and Streamlining: The updated regulations are designed to reduce administrative burden and complexity, making it easier for participants to navigate the program requirements. Changes include clarified guidelines and updated processes to improve efficiency and accessibility. Alignment with Other Federal Housing Programs: The revisions harmonize HOME program regulations with other federal housing initiatives, such as the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and Section 8 Housing Choice Voucher programs. This alignment facilitates cohesive and complementary use of federal housing resources. Implementation of Recent Statutory Amendments: The final rule incorporates recent amendments to the HOME statute, ensuring compliance with current legislative mandates. Applicability: The revised regulations apply to developments for which HOME funds are committed on or after 30 days following the publication date effectively starting February 5, 2025. Background on the Final Rule The final rule follows the publication of a proposed rule on May 29, 2024. HUD received and reviewed extensive feedback from stakeholders during the comment period, resulting in adjustments to ensure the regulations address both practical challenges and statutory requirements. Minor revisions were also made to CDBG and Section 8 program regulations to align with the updated HOME program rules. Implications for Affordable Housing Stakeholders For Developers: Developers planning to utilize HOME funds for projects must familiarize themselves with the updated requirements to ensure compliance. Streamlined processes may expedite project approvals and reduce administrative delays. For Public Housing Agencies (PHAs) and Local Governments: Agencies administering HOME funds will benefit from more precise regulations and enhanced alignment with other federal housing programs. Training and resources may be required to adapt to the new requirements. For Tenants and Communities: The updates aim to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of HOME-funded projects, resulting in improved housing opportunities for low-income families. Next Steps HUD encourages all stakeholders to review the final rule in detail and assess its impact on their operations and strategies. Additional guidance and training materials are expected to be released to assist in the transition to the updated regulations. Conclusion The final rule represents a significant step forward in modernizing the HOME program and optimizing its role in addressing the nation s affordable housing needs. Stakeholders must promptly align with the updated requirements and capitalize on the improved processes. Shortly, I will post an article on the A. J. Johnson Consulting Services website outlining the most significant HOME rules changes, especially those that will impact management operations at projects utilizing HOME funds.

HUD Extends HOTMA Compliance Deadline for Community Planning and Development Programs to 2026

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) has announced an extension of the compliance deadline for implementing specific provisions of the Housing Opportunity Through Modernization Act (HOTMA) final rule for Community Planning and Development (CPD) programs. This extension will be official when published in the Federal Register on December 31, 2024. Key Points: The extension applies to multiple programs including HOME Investment Partnerships, HOME-American Rescue Plan, Housing Trust Fund (HTF), Housing Opportunities for Persons With AIDS (HOPWA), Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), Emergency Solution Grants (ESG), and Continuum of Care (CoC) programs. CPD grantees must comply with the HOTMA final rule by January 1, 2026, but they may choose to implement the changes earlier, starting from January 1, 2024. HUD cited delays in updating its systems and the need to provide grantees additional time to incorporate new income and asset requirements into their programs as reasons for the extension. Safe Harbor Provisions: The notice also allows certain CPD grantees to implement income safe harbor provisions before the extended compliance date: HOPWA, ESG, and CoC program grantees may use the safe harbor provision at 24 CFR 5.609(c)(3). HOME and HTF grantees can implement specific safe harbor provisions under their regulations. Grantees must update their program guidelines and establish appropriate policies before using these provisions. Background: This extension follows earlier announcements affecting other HUD programs: In September 2024, the Office of Public and Indian Housing (PIH) announced that Public Housing Agencies would not need to implement certain HOTMA provisions by January 2025. The Office of Housing issued a similar notification extending the deadline to July 1, 2025 for multifamily owners. Until their new compliance dates, CPD grantees must continue following existing regulations as they were before January 1, 2024, while having the option to implement the new safe harbor provisions described in the notice. The extension aims to ensure a smoother transition to the new requirements while reducing the administrative burden on grantees who may otherwise need to maintain two different income requirements for the same units.

Want news delivered to your inbox?

Subscribe to our news articles to stay up to date.

We care about the protection of your data. Read our Privacy Policy.