HUD Provides Guidance on Non-Rent Fees for Subsidized Multifamily Housing Programs

person A.J. Johnson today 03/16/2024

In February 2024, the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) provided guidance on existing policies regarding the fees that owners may and may not charge tenants. None of the guidance is new or reflects any change in HUD regulations. The purpose of the guidance is twofold: (1) to remind owners of the current requirements relative to fees and (2) to seek input from stakeholders on any possible changes to the requirements.

Following is an overview of existing HUD policy regarding fees in addition to rent.

  • Application Fees: Owners may not require fees or other costs to accept and process applications. These costs are considered project expenses.
  • Charges at Initial Occupancy: Owners may not collect any money from tenants at initial occupancy other than rent and the maximum HUD-allowed security deposit unless they receive HUD approval to do otherwise.
  • Pet Deposit: An owner of housing specifically designed for occupancy by the elderly and persons with disabilities may require tenants to pay a refundable pet deposit. The pet deposit applies only to tenants who own or keep cats or dogs in their units. HUD Handbook 4350.3 outlines the maximum amount of the pet deposit that may be charged by an owner on a per-unit basis.
    • An owner may use the pet deposit only to pay reasonable expenses directly attributable to the pet's presence on the property, including (but not limited to) the cost of repairs and replacements to, and fumigation of, the unit and the cost of animal care facilities. Owners must return the unused portion of a pet deposit to the tenant within a reasonable time after the tenant moves from the property or no longer owns or keeps a pet in the unit.
  • Screening Fees: Owners may not charge applicants for costs associated with screening applicants, including screening for criminal history or verifying income and eligibility. Hence, owners must not require applicants to pay credit report charges, charges for home visits, charges to obtain police reports or other costs associated with the above functions. These costs are considered project expenses.
  • Security Deposit: Owners may collect a security deposit during the initial lease execution. However, the owner must collect a refundable security deposit at the time of the initial lease execution for the following programs:
    • Section 8 New Construction with an AHAP executed on or after November 5, 1979;
    • Section 8 Substantial Rehabilitation with an AHAP executed on or after February 20, 1980;
    • Section 8 State Agency with an AHAP executed on or after February 29, 1980;
    • Section 202/8;
    • Section 202 PAC;
    • Section 202 PRAC; and
    • Section 811 PRAC.

Owners may collect the security deposit on an installment basis. The security deposit amount established at move-in does not change when a tenant’s rent changes. The amount of the security deposit to be collected is dependent upon:

  1. The type of housing program;
  2. The date the AHAP or HAP contract for the unit was signed and
  3. The amount of the total tenant payment or tenant rent.

The HUD Handbook 4350.3, Figure 6-7, outlines the security deposit amount that may be collected for each program.

When a tenant transfers to a new unit, an owner may:

  1. Transfer the security deposit, or
  2. Charge a new deposit and refund the deposit for the old unit.
  1. Assistance Animals: Owners may not require an applicant or tenant to pay a fee or a security deposit as a condition of allowing the applicant or tenant to keep an assistance animal. However, if an assistance animal causes damage to the unit or common areas of the dwelling, the owner may charge the individual for the cost of repairing the damage if the owner regularly charges tenants for any damage they cause to the premises.
  2. Attorney/Legal Costs: There may be no lease provision that the tenant agrees to pay all attorney and other legal costs if the owner brings legal action against the tenant, even if the tenant prevails.  However, as a party to a lawsuit, a tenant may be obligated to pay attorney’s fees or other costs if the tenant loses the suit.
    1. Owners may accept payment of court filing, attorney, and sheriff fees from tenants who wish to avoid or settle an eviction suit provided it is permitted under state and local laws, and the fees appear reasonable and do not exceed the actual costs incurred.
  3. Bad Behavior: Owners may not charge tenants for bad behavior, such as foul language, noise, or failure to supervise children.
  4. Checks Returned for Insufficient Funds: Owners may impose a fee on the second time, and each additional time thereafter, a check is not honored for payment. The owner may bill a tenant only for the amount the bank charges for processing the returned check.
    1. HUD or a Contract Administrator (CA) may authorize additional charges if such charges are consistent with local management practices and are permitted under state and local law.
    1. Owners of Section 202/8, Section 202 PAC, Section 202 PRAC, and Section 811 PRAC projects may never charge fees for checks returns for insufficient funds.
  5. Damages: Whenever damage is caused by carelessness, misuse, or neglect by the tenant, household member, or visitor, the tenant is obligated to reimburse the owner within 30 days of receiving a bill from the owner. The owner’s bill is limited to actual and reasonable costs incurred by the owner for repairing the damages.
  6. Facilities & Services: Owners may not charge tenants separately for equipment and services included in the rent. Owners may charge tenants for other services or facilities (e.g., cable TV or use of community space in the project) only if all of the following conditions are met:
    1. Part C of the most recently approved rent schedule includes the services, facilities, and charges.
    1. A schedule of those charges has been posted or distributed to the tenants.
    1. The tenant can use those facilities or services if they are optional.
    1. If not previously authorized, the charges must be approved by HUD before implementation.

Owners may charge for parking only in unsubsidized projects where HUD previously approved it. They may also charge for car heaters in cold climates where parking spaces are equipped with them.

  • Infestation Treatment: Owners may not charge a tenant for the extermination cost unless the owner can demonstrate that the tenant's carelessness or neglect caused the infestation.
  • Keys & Lockouts: Owners may charge tenants for answering lock-out calls and providing extra keys. At the time of move-out, the owner may charge the tenant for unreturned keys.
  • Late Payment of Rent: Owners may charge a late fee if the tenant has been given at least five calendar days as a grace period to pay the rent. The rent must be received by the fifth day, not postmarked on that day. On the sixth day, the owner may charge a fee not to exceed $5.00 for the period of the first through fifth day that the rent is not paid. After that, the owner may charge a fee of $1.00 per day for each additional day the rent remains unpaid for the month.
    • HUD or CAs may approve a higher initial late fee if (1) it is permitted under state and local laws, (2) it is consistent with local management practices, and (3) the total late charge assessed for the month does not exceed $30.00.

An owner may deduct accrued, unpaid late charges from the security deposit at the time of move-out if such a deduction is permitted under state and local laws. An owner may not evict a tenant for failure to pay late charges.

Owners of Section 202/8, Section 202 PAC, Section 202 PRAC, and Section 811 PRAC projects may never charge late rent payment fees.

  • Meals Fee: Owners of properties for the elderly or persons with disabilities for which HUD approved a mandatory meals program before April 1, 1987, may charge a HUD-approved meals fee. The tenants pay such costs, and the fees are not rent.
  • Meeting Space for Tenant Organizations: An owner may charge a reasonable fee, approved by HUD, as may normally be imposed for using such facilities in accordance with procedures prescribed by HUD for the use of meeting space.
  • Other Charges: Owners may require tenants to pay other charges if:
    • HUD or CA has approved the charges, and
    • The schedule of charges is either:
      • Listed in the lease agreement or
      • Has been distributed to all tenants in accordance with the modification of the lease requirements and procedures listed in paragraph 6-12D of Handbook 4350.3.

HUD’s Office of Multifamily Housing Programs is seeking feedback from stakeholders regarding these policies. Owners and Agents of affected programs may provide comments and feedback to HUD at AssetManagementPolicy@HUD.gov. Responses are due by March 29, 2024.

Latest Articles

A. J. Johnson Offers Live Webinar on Tenant-on-Tenant Harassment

A. J. Johnson will conduct a webinar on June 20, 2024, on Navigating the Challenges Dealing with Tenant-on-Tenant Harassment in Multifamily Housing. The Webinar will be held from 1:00 PM to 2:00 PM Eastern time. Attending a webinar on Tenant-on-Tenant Harassment is crucial for multifamily housing professionals for several reasons: Understanding Legal Responsibilities: Gain insight into federal, state, and local laws regarding tenant harassment and the responsibilities of housing providers in preventing and addressing such issues. Enhancing Tenant Safety: Learn strategies to create a safe and respectful living environment, thereby reducing the risk of harassment and ensuring the well-being of all tenants. Improving Conflict Resolution Skills: Develop skills to effectively mediate and resolve conflicts between tenants, which can prevent harassment situations from escalating. Protecting Property Reputation: Learn the impact of tenant harassment on the property's reputation and how proactive management can enhance community perception and tenant satisfaction. Minimizing Legal Risks: Learn about the potential legal ramifications of tenant-on-tenant harassment and how to mitigate these risks through proper documentation, response protocols, and preventative measures. Compliance and Best Practices: Stay updated on best practices and compliance requirements to ensure the property meets all legal standards and fosters a harassment-free environment. Enhancing Staff Training: Acquire knowledge that can be used to train staff members to recognize, prevent, and respond effectively to tenant harassment. Creating a Positive Community: Foster a positive, inclusive, and respectful community culture that can improve tenant retention and satisfaction. By attending this webinar, multifamily housing professionals can equip themselves with the necessary tools and knowledge to handle tenant-on-tenant harassment effectively, ensuring a harmonious living environment and safeguarding their property s reputation and legal standing. Those interested in participating in the Webinar may register on the A. J. Johnson Consulting Services website (www.ajjcs.net) under "Training Schedule.

HUD Proposed Changes to HOME Program are Comprehensive

On May 15, 2024, HUD published a preview of a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking proposing significant changes to the HOME Program. The proposed rule is expected to be published in the Federal Register before June, and public comments are due no later than 60 days after that publication. The proposed rule would make changes in many areas: Community Housing Development Organization (CHDO) Requirements: Major revisions to CHDO requirements are proposed to streamline processes and improve efficiency. HOME Rents Approach: A new methodology for setting HOME rents is being introduced to better align with current housing market conditions. Small-Scale Rental Projects: Requirements for small-scale rental projects will be simplified, making it easier for developers to comply. HOME Tenant-Based Rental Assistance (TBRA) Programs: The proposed changes will provide greater flexibility in TBRA programs, allowing for more effective tenant support. Community Land Trusts (CLTs): New flexibilities and simplified provisions are being proposed to encourage their use and effectiveness. Tenant Protections: The rule would significantly strengthen tenant protections by mandating a HOME tenancy addendum with a uniform set of protections to be included in leases of all HOME-assisted rental housing units. For tenants receiving TBRA, a streamlined set of protections will be required. Advanced Property Standards: HUD proposes incentives for meeting higher property standards incorporating green building practices, enhanced energy efficiency, and innovative construction techniques for new construction, reconstruction, and rehabilitation projects. Homeownership Housing Resale Requirements: Clarifications to resale requirements for homeownership housing are included to ensure transparency and consistency. Technical Amendments and Simplifications: The proposed rule will make technical amendments and simplifications to align with the changes introduced in the 2013 HOME Final Rule. These proposed changes are part of a broader effort to modernize and improve the HOME program, incorporating updates from the Housing Opportunity Through Modernization Act of 2016 (HOTMA), the Economic Growth Regulatory Relief and Consumer Protection Act, and the National Standards for the Physical Inspection of Real Estate (NSPIRE) Final Rule. Additionally, the rule updates citations to align with recent changes to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) regulations at 2 CFR part 200. HUD plans to publish further rulemaking to ensure consistency across all regulations. The proposed changes are detailed in the Proposed Regulation, with further revisions anticipated following the implementation of the HOTMA and NSPIRE Final Rules. While all the proposed changes are important, what follows is a discussion of the proposed changes in four specific areas: (1) Small-scale housing, (2) HOME rents, (3) Tenant Protections, and (4) Advanced Property Standards. Small-scale housing. HUD proposes to add the definition of "small-scale housing, which would be defined as a rental housing project containing no more than four units or a homeownership project with no more than three rental units on the same site. HUD proposes this definition to permit these projects to follow streamlined procedures for income determinations, ongoing physical inspections, and written tenant waiting lists. The definition and the streamlined provisions would facilitate the participation of owners of small rental properties (e.g., accessory dwelling units, duplexes, triplexes, or other small rental projects) in the HOME program. For small-scale projects, HUD would provide an exception from requiring a PJ to adopt a more frequent inspection schedule for properties with health and safety deficiencies. If all health and safety deficiencies are corrected, the proposed rule permits but does not require more frequent inspection schedules. HUD plans to develop a specific list of deficiencies for small-scale rental housing that a PJ would inspect. The proposed rule would reduce burdens on landlords of small-scale housing by allowing for the reexamination of tenant income every three years rather than annually. Tenant-Based Rental Assistance: Eligible Costs and Requirements (24 CFR 92.209). The proposed rule would revise 92.209(c)(1) to eliminate the requirement that adjusted income be determined annually for families receiving TBRA. Because TBRA contracts are limited by statute to two years and must be executed every time a tenant enters into a new lease, the proposed rule would permit a PJ to provide TBRA to a family and not redetermine adjusted income during the contract s period of assistance. Tenants will be able to request interims when income goes down, but PJs will not have to conduct interims for increases in income during the contract term. Change in HOME Rent Rules: Unlike the current HOME rule, which permits HOME rents to be exceeded only for low-HOME units when there is project-based rental assistance, the proposed rule will permit HOME rents to be exceeded anytime there is project-based rental assistance. This change would apply to both Low and High-HOME units. Tenant Protections: The Department proposes significant revisions to the tenant protections and selection provisions in 92.253, consistent with the priorities in the Administration s Renters Bill of Rights. These tenant protections are based on the Department s review of existing HUD programs (e.g., the Section 8 PBV and public housing programs). To implement the tenant protections, HUD proposes requiring all tenants in HOME-assisted rental housing units or receiving TBRA to have a new HOME tenancy addendum appended to their lease. Among the proposed tenant protections: Leases will contain more than one convenient method to communicate directly with the owner or the property management staff, including in-person, by telephone, email, or through a web portal. The proposed rule will outline new tenant protections regarding the physical condition of units, including a requirement that owners provide tenants with expected timeframes for maintaining and repairing units as soon as practicable. When a life-threatening deficiency in the physical condition of the unit impacts the tenant, owners are required to relocate the tenant into safe housing, which may be either on or off-site. Families can reside with a foster child, foster adult, or live-in aide in the unit. The revised HOME Lease Addendum will include a section outlining when owners may enter a tenant s unit. Reasons include routine inspections and maintenance, repairs, and showing units to prospective tenants. At least two days' notice will be required, including the purpose for entering the unit. An exception to the notice requirement will be made for emergencies. The proposed rule would require that an owner who enters a unit when the tenant and all adult household members are absent from the unit must provide a written statement to the tenant explaining the date, time, and purpose of their entry into the unit. Properties with HOME funds will not be able to have separate amenities such as gyms, pools, spas, elevators, rooftop gardens, storage areas, and playrooms that only non-assisted tenants can use or access. Tenants can organize, create tenant associations, convene meetings, distribute literature, and post information at a project. The proposed rule would include new security deposit requirements. The security deposit amount could not exceed two months' rent, and surety bonds or security deposit insurance would be prohibited. Owners cannot terminate the tenancy of HOME tenants without good cause, and the rule outlines many examples of "good cause. Advanced Property Standards: All projects built or rehabilitated with HOME funds must comply with all state and local building codes. PJs will be required to perform physical inspections on an annual basis. Property standards and inspections will generally be done per NSPIRE standards. Carbon Monoxide detectors will be required in all HOME-assisted units. Although reconstruction is considered rehabilitation for the HOME program, the property standards for new construction will be applied to all HOME-assisted reconstruction projects. When entering a rental assistance contract, PJs must annually provide physical inspections of all HOME-assisted units. This requirement applies to tenant-based rental assistance only. The proposed rule would require the initial inspection of HOME-assisted rental housing within 12 months of project completion and once every three years thereafter. If deficiencies are observed in any of the inspectable areas, a follow-up onsite inspection to verify that deficiencies are corrected must occur within 12 months. The PJ may establish a list of non-hazardous deficiencies for which correction can be verified by third-party documentation (e.g., paid invoice for work order) rather than re-inspection. Bottom Line These changes aim to modernize and improve the HOME program, incorporating updates from recent legislative acts and ensuring consistency across all regulations. Owners should review these proposed changes thoroughly to understand their implications and provide feedback during the public comment period.

A. J. Johnson Partners with Mid-Atlantic AHMA for Affordable Housing Training - July 2024

In July 2024, A. J. Johnson, a renowned expert in the field, will join forces with the esteemed Mid-Atlantic Affordable Housing Management Association to conduct training for real estate professionals. This session, tailored for those in the affordable multifamily housing field, will be delivered through a live webinar. The following session is scheduled: July 16: Budgeting 101 for Multifamily Housing This comprehensive three-hour course provides a foundational understanding of budgeting and financial management specific to affordable multifamily housing. It will equip property managers with the essential skills to evaluate and manage operating funds, maximize net operating income (NOI), and ensure accurate financial reporting. Key Discussion Areas: Introduction to Budgeting & Financial Management:Importance of tracking income and expenses Overview of cash receipts, expenditures, reserves, and security deposits Evaluation of Operating Funds: Understanding profitability and return on investment (ROI) for rental real estate The Cash Flow Chart:Definition and significance of Net Operating Income (NOI) Owner s assessment of pre-tax and after-tax cash flow Gross Potential Rental Income: Calculation and importance of maximum rent income Vacancy & Collection Loss:Measures of vacancy (physical and economic) Impact of vacancies and collection losses on gross potential rental income Miscellaneous Income: Sources of additional income beyond scheduled rent Effective Gross Income: Calculations involving vacancy and collection loss and miscellaneous income Operating Expenses: Categories of operating expenses, including payroll, maintenance, utilities, and more Net Operating Income (NOI): Importance of maximizing NOI as a measure of management success Debt Service: Explanation of debt service and its impact on financial management Cash Flow: Calculation of cash flow and its importance in financial management Income and Expense Categories: Detailed discussion on various income and expense categories Budgeting:Types of budgets: operating, capital, and long-range Annual budgeting process and importance of quarterly updates Operating Budget: Monthly planning and detailed allocation of income and expenses Annual Budget:Historical vs. zero-based budgeting Review and approval process with property owners Capital and Long-Range Budget: Planning for future capital expenditures and long-term financial forecasting Summary: Key takeaways on maximizing NOI, effective budgeting, and financial management in multifamily housing Learning Objectives: Develop Financial Management Skills: Understand the basics of budgeting, financial tracking, and reporting. Maximize Property Income: Learn techniques to increase NOI and manage operating expenses efficiently. Effective Budget Planning: Gain knowledge on creating accurate operating, capital, and long-range budgets. Improve Financial Decision-Making: Enhance ability to make informed financial decisions to benefit property operations. Target Audience: Property Managers Financial Officers Asset Managers Compliance Officers in the multifamily housing sector Conclusion: Budgeting 101 for Multifamily Housing provides essential training for managing the financial aspects of affordable housing properties. By the end of the course, participants will be equipped with the knowledge and tools necessary to ensure financial health and sustainability for their properties. This session is part of a year-long collaboration between A. J. Johnson and MidAtlantic AHMA designed to provide affordable housing professionals with the knowledge needed to effectively manage the complex requirements of the various agencies overseeing these programs. Persons interested in this training may register by visiting either www.ajjcs.net or https://www.mid-atlanticahma.org.

Want news delivered to your inbox?

Subscribe to our news articles to stay up to date.

We care about the protection of your data. Read our Privacy Policy.